Pessimism and Optimism
We have hyped optimism over the years. As a psychological disposition, we describe optimism as a mental attitude reflecting a belief or hope that the outcome of an endeavour will be positive, favourable and desirable. At every turn, we encourage others to be hopeful and confident about the future or the success of something. Researchers have posited that optimism improves the quality of life and ensures happiness and success. They also claim that optimism has health benefits such as buffering the negative effects of a physical illness.
On the other hand, we widely discourage pessimism. As a psychological disposition, we describe pessimism as a negative or depressed mental attitude. With pessimism, we anticipate an undesirable outcome from a given situation. It is a tendency whereby we see the worst aspect of things or believe that the worst will happen.
Despite the fact that we perceive optimism as positive and pessimism as negative, could there be any positive aspect of pessimism? Can we say that pessimism is a viable alternative to optimism?
Positive Aspect of Pessimism
We see the positive aspect of pessimism in the theory of defensive pessimism. The theory of defensive pessimism proposes that imagining and planning for worst-case scenarios can be more effective than trying to think positively. Nancy Cantor and her students identified this cognitive strategy in the mid 1980s. People who have high levels of anxiety use this strategy to help them manage their anxiety so that they can work productively. Defensive pessimists lower their expectations to help prepare themselves for the worst. This is because, according to Norem and Chang, they do best when they can think through possible negative outcomes.
There are some benefits of defensive pessimism. Firstly, since defensive pessimists have low expectations, they do not get unduly disappointed if things do not work out as planned. For instance, when expecting the results of a job interview, not being taken for the job will not throw defensive pessimists into the depths of despair. This is because of their low expectations in the first place.
Secondly, since defensive pessimists are negative, they imagine the worst-case scenario and prepare for the worst. As a result, they adequately prepare to face adversity. As such, adversity does not throw them into a state of shock when it occurs. For instance, while waiting for the doctor for news about the outcome of a surgery on a loved one, defensive pessimists tune their minds that death is an option. As such, they are not devastated when the doctor informs them that the patient has passed on.
Thirdly, because of their fear of failure, defensive pessimists are meticulous planners. When faced with a challenge, they consider the possible pitfalls and plug all the possible loopholes. As such, defensive pessimists are more likely to extensively plan and prepare for an examination. They, therefore, leave no stone unturned since they do not want to fail.
Is Pessimism a viable alternative to Optimism?
Can these positive traits of pessimism make it a viable alternative to optimism?
Although we describe pessimists as moody and gloomy, which is a drawback and we describe optimists as cheerful and sunny, which is an advantage, could there be any disadvantages to optimism?
In contrast to defensive pessimism, strategic optimism is the setting of high expectations where one does not think much about what might happen. People with low levels of anxiety use this strategy. According to Norem and Chang, strategic optimists do best when they avoid thinking about possible negative outcomes. However, can this attribute of strategic optimists put them in the category of people who bury their heads in the sand, that is, who refuse to deal with unpleasant realities by pretending that they do not exist?
We see the people that we describe as overly optimistic to be over-confident and to engage in wishful thinking. We also note the attribute of optimism bias. This is a cognitive bias that leads to a tendency to overestimate the likelihood of positive outcomes. It also involves a tendency to downplay the possibility of negative outcomes. These attributes may lead to risky behaviour. This is because they may prevent overly optimistic people from adequately planning for the future.
Which of these two, a defensive pessimist or a strategic optimist, is in a better position to prepare for a storm, whether literally or figuratively? The defensive pessimist will carry an umbrella and wear protective clothing in the face of an impending storm. As a result of the negative mindset of a defensive pessimist in anticipating the storms of life, he or she will also plan accordingly. As such, he or she will be in a position to weather these storms whenever they occur.
The strategic optimist, on the other hand may be ill-prepared for a storm both literally and figuratively. Literally, this is because he or she may believe that it will not rain and thus see no need for an umbrella or protective clothing. Figuratively, since the strategic optimist avoids the thought of possible negative outcomes in life, he or she may focus only on the positive. The strategic optimist is thus shocked when major setbacks occur.
In “The Upside of Defensive Pessimism: the Potential Benefits of Anxiety”, Joaquin Selva notes that some people benefit from defensive pessimism and others benefit from strategic optimism. She states that no single method is better for everybody. We may be add that what may be good for each person depends on their individual temperaments and their levels of anxiety.
Conclusion
If, at the end of the day, we achieve the maximum output in whatever endeavour that is at stake, does it matter whether we achieved it through strategic optimism or defensive pessimism? Does the end not justify the means? In that case, can we say that pessimism is a viable alternative to optimism?
The British Statesman, Winston Churchill, stated as follows: “The pessimist sees difficulty in every opportunity. The optimist sees the opportunity in every difficulty.”
What do you see?
Your comments are welcome. Please post a comment by clicking on the chat icon beneath the heading.
Regardless of whether you see opportunity or difficulty, you need to shield your eyes from the glare of the sun. What better way to do so than to put on a pair of sunglasses which are also a fashion statement and make you feel classy? Kindly check out these Salvatore Ferragamo Womens Havana/Gold Sunglasses as shown below. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
The men are not to be left out. You should also shield your eyes from the sun in style. Kindly check out these stylish Tory Burch Sunglasses as shown below. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Do not miss out on our interesting topics. Please subscribe below to get updates delivered straight into your inbox:
Excellent article!
No matter how much hope one can have or how optimistic their outlook is things will not always go as planned or turn out well or as expected.
There is no wrong in sometimes expecting the worst as it is a reality in life that happens and that some people correctly portend.
When one weighs both sides and do not expect too much they absolutely will not get disappointed. We need to be both optimistic and pessimistic at times this is a healthy way of going through life.
Thanks so much for your insightful comments and your support! 🙏
We need a healthy balance of both optimism and pessimism!
Pingback:How to Embrace and Optimise Sadness: A Choice
Pingback:How to Apply the Soothing Balm of Self-Deception 2023
The end justifies the means!! Great piece Madam
In Disaster Management, simulation exercises are designed based on defensive pessimism. We simulate and respond to the worst case scenario so we are not taken aback irrespective of the magnitude or intensity of the shock.
In a similar vein strategic optimism pushes us to fight the shock and remain undaunted. In a sense, defensive pessimism and strategic optimism are siblings filling complimentary roles.
Thanks a lot for the disaster management perspective.
The desire in a man works magic. Sometimes, situations may look bleak but your positive strong feelings of wanting to stay on to achieve the expected results come with great smiles at the end.
Therefore, whatever you desire is what you get. Though there might be changes, it’s an experience to get better and stronger to get going.
“Never give up” is the courage.
Thanks for the knowledge madam
For me it does not matter how ? The end justifies the means. I normally weigh the situation and adjust my strategy appropriately but it suffices to say that positive pessimism allows you to plan and also reduces our level of stress and other consequences that go with disappointments. In all situations we should be ready for disappointment which allows us to keep on pushing till we reach our goals in life.
So true.
During my younger years, I always thought it was healthier to be an optimist than a pessimist. However, my life experiences have taught me that it is balance that keeps us going.
True, a balance is necessary.
This thing is so real, but could it also be possible that you can be a pessimist {defensively} at one time and an optimist {strategic} at another?
A balanced life won’t be bad.
Another mind-titillating piece! Indeed it is the optimists who manufactured the fastest aircrafts! It is the pessimists who manufactured the parachutes! When the two are combined, the result is safe air travel! As in every phenomenon, as Karl Marx posits, there exists the principles of dialectical materialism! Kudos my Lady!
Thanks so much!
A joyful/hopeful heart is good medicine, but pessimism drains one’s strength. Can you imagine a tomorrow without optimism? Certainly, pessimism is NOT an option!
Thanks for your comment.
Great piece Madam.
I always recommend a well considered balance to living. In this life where there are really no guarantees other than death and taxes, it is imperative that we apply both concepts whenever we can.
I believe that both defensive pessimism and strategic optimism are necessary under different situations for each individual.
I will prescribe that since we are not really fixed in our personalities but rather circumstances determine us, we should not also just choose to go with just one concept and therefore yes, pessimism must be a viable alternative to optimism.
Things seldomly go according to desire, design or plan in this life.
See the movie “Trolls” for a very illustrative depiction of the discussion.
Great illuminating piece indeed.
Thanks for your insight.
Intriguing.
Thanks
On the 27th of March 2018 I was taken to the theater room for a prostate enlargement surgery, the surgeon was surprised to have recorded very good statistics. He asked me “Mr Acquah you appear very relaxed, what is your secret” I replied “to live is for Christ and to die is gain, so whether I return alive or dead is beneficial to me” by that statement I had a very easy and successful surgery. So in conclusion one does not always have to be very optimistic.
True.
Defensive pessimism Can work for so many people, the least you expect the lower the dissatisfaction .
A good write up
Thanks.
Like Joaquin Selva, I think the end justifies the means. Hence any of the two psychological dispositions could be beneficial in an endeavour depending on a person’s temperament. But a blend of the two psychological dispositions in a person should be very beneficial.
Wow. I am a serious optimist. I never knew pessimism has any positive sides. This is really enlightening
True.